Both are things people cook, and that sets this comparison apart from the rest of the category. Reishi, chaga and turkey tail are woody brackets nobody eats for dinner, so every human study of them used a prepared extract. Maitake and shiitake arrive in kitchens, and one of the two trials below used plain dried mushrooms at an ordinary food portion rather than an extract.
Maitake grows as a rosette of overlapping fronds at the base of oaks. Shiitake grows as a single capped mushroom, commercially on hardwood logs or on supplemented sawdust. The distinction that matters on a supplement label is still fruiting body against mycelium grown on grain, because grain carries starch, starch is an alpha-glucan, and alpha-glucan inflates any figure printed as total polysaccharide. Both species enter the Endoca range as fruiting body extracts.
Species identity on a milled powder cannot be confirmed by eye, and DNA barcoding of the internal transcribed spacer region is the method that does it. Shiitake has also changed genus, moving from Lentinus to Lentinula, so two perfectly accurate labels can look like two different mushrooms.
Beta-glucan is a subtraction, not a measurement. Total glucan is hydrolyzed with sulfuric acid and the released glucose measured; alpha-glucan is measured separately by digesting starch and glycogen with glucoamylase; beta-glucan is what remains. Anything carrying starch reports a high total glucan and a much smaller beta-glucan, so a label giving only the total has told you nothing useful.
Maitake complicates this in a way grain-substrate products do not. An alpha-glucan has been isolated from the Grifola frondosa fruiting body itself, so maitake carries alpha-glucan natively. A genuine, fruiting-body-only maitake extract will still lose some of its total glucan figure to the subtraction, and that is correct rather than a sign of adulteration.
Shiitake is the species where the detection reagent changes the answer most. An alkaline-extracted glucan fraction from Lentinula edodes read higher on a recombinant glucan recognition protein than it did on a polyclonal antibody, so the reagent itself changes the number, not only the extraction. Reviews of mushroom glucans are blunt that figures only compare within one method, which is why a figure without its method is not a figure.
Both columns describe immune markers measured over three to four weeks in fewer than 90 people. The maitake trial is the more interesting because it came out untidy: more was not better, and some readouts fell. The one survival finding belongs to injected lentinan under oncology care.
For food, cook both and cook the shiitake thoroughly, because the compound implicated in the rash is heat labile. For a supplement, read the Latin name, confirm the part used is fruiting body, and check whether the glucan figure names its extraction and assay method. Treat any product citing the lentinan gastric cancer data as misrepresenting itself. Maitake is the better documented for an oral extract, but its one trial is a caution as much as a result. On chemotherapy or immunosuppressive treatment, raise the non-monotonic maitake finding with your oncologist first.
Still weighing up the options? See Chaga vs turkey tail or Turkey tail vs reishi. For more background, read our guide on what to check on a mushroom supplement label. Endoca products related to this comparison: Maitake Mushroom Extract and Shiitake products.
Both species are ordinary foods and are also sold as dietary supplements under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, which permits structure and function statements and prohibits any claim to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent disease. Lentinan is not approved by the Food and Drug Administration as a cancer therapy here, and survival data generated with injected lentinan cannot be used to market a capsule or a gummy.
Because both are foods with a long history of consumption, neither faces the novel ingredient questions that apply to concentrated extracts of non-food fungi.
Shiitake dermatitis is the specific hazard. The mechanism is thought to involve lentinan, a heat-labile polysaccharide, by either a partial toxic effect or a Th1-type hypersensitivity response, and eating shiitake raw or undercooked can produce intensely itchy linear streaks across the trunk and limbs. French poison centers logged 59 cases among 125 shiitake exposures between 2014 and 2019, with onset from 1 to 168 hours, a median of 48 hours, and duration from 1 to 40 days. Corticosteroids and antihistamines were given to 38 patients without demonstrated benefit. A 2026 case report describes the same rash after mushroom coffee, so powders are not exempt.
Maitake was tolerated without dose-limiting toxicity in its trial, with two withdrawals for nausea with joint swelling and for rash with itching. Neither species has been studied in pregnancy or breastfeeding.
Maitake and shiitake both sit inside the Organic Mushroom Immune Complex, 300 mg of blended fruiting body extract per serving across 30 capsules, and shiitake also appears as Shiitake Mushroom Gummies. Every batch is third-party tested, with the certificate of analysis published through the lab portal, covering identity, heavy metals, pesticide residues and microbial load. The gummy publishes no milligram figure per serving. Endoca has worked from its own farm, own land and own extraction since 2010.
Neither is well studied. Maitake has one phase 1/2 trial in 34 breast cancer patients over 3 weeks; shiitake has one 4-week trial in 52 healthy adults. Both measured immune markers rather than illness. The larger shiitake dataset belongs to injected lentinan, not to the mushroom.
An itchy, whip-like rash on the trunk and limbs after eating raw or undercooked shiitake, attributed to lentinan, which is heat labile. French poison centers recorded 59 cases among 125 shiitake exposures. It lasted a median of 10 days and all patients recovered.
Not according to the only oral dose-escalation trial. Increasing doses raised some immunologic parameters and depressed others, and the curves were non-monotonic, so intermediate doses sometimes did more than high ones. The investigators noted botanicals may suppress immune function as well as stimulate it.
Because the figure is a subtraction and depends on extraction and assay. Beta-glucan is total glucan minus alpha-glucan, and in one study an alkaline-extracted Lentinula edodes fraction read higher on a recombinant glucan recognition protein than on a polyclonal antibody. Published reviews are clear that values only compare within a single method.
No. Maitake has a feathery texture and a rich, earthy flavour, while shiitake is meatier with a stronger umami taste. Both are widely eaten as food.
Yes, they are often combined in food and supplements and no interaction is known. People sensitive to raw shiitake should cook it thoroughly.
Deng G, Lin H, Seidman A, et al. A phase I/II trial of a polysaccharide extract from Grifola frondosa (Maitake mushroom) in breast cancer patients: immunological effects. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 2009;135(9):1215-1221.
Dai X, Stanilka JM, Rowe CA, et al. Consuming Lentinula edodes (shiitake) mushrooms daily improves human immunity: a randomized dietary intervention in healthy young adults. J Am Coll Nutr. 2015;34(6):478-487.
Oba K, Kobayashi M, Matsui T, et al. Individual patient based meta-analysis of lentinan for unresectable/recurrent gastric cancer. Anticancer Res. 2009;29(7):2739-2745.
Boels D, Greillet C, Langrand J, et al. Shiitake dermatitis: experience of the Poison Control Centre Network in France from 2014 to 2019. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2022;60(8):954-959.
Eubanks BN, Linabury JF, Kumetz EA. Shiitake dermatitis and potential implications for military readiness. Mil Med. 2023;188(9-10):3285-3288.
Mijares J, Ramachandran V. Flagellate erythema from mushroom coffee: a novel exposure route for shiitake dermatitis. Int J Dermatol. 2026; doi:10.1111/ijd.70497.
McCleary BV, Draga A. Measurement of beta-glucan in mushrooms and mycelial products. J AOAC Int. 2016;99(2):364-373.
Kanno T, Adachi Y, Ishibashi KI, et al. Quantification of beta-glucan from culinary-medicinal mushrooms using novel artificial beta-glucan recognition protein. Int J Med Mushrooms. 2020;22(3):269-276.
Vetter J. The mushroom glucans: molecules of high biological and medicinal importance. Foods. 2023;12(5):1009.
Lei H, Zhang M, Wang Q, et al. MT-alpha-glucan from the fruit body of the maitake medicinal mushroom Grifola frondosa shows protective effects for hypoglycemic pancreatic beta-cells. Int J Med Mushrooms. 2013;15(4):373-381.
Raja HA, Baker TR, Little JG, Oberlies NH. DNA barcoding for identification of consumer-relevant mushrooms: a partial solution for product certification? Food Chem. 2017;214:383-392.
Last reviewed 1 October 2026.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.